the-social-media-ban-is-finally-in-the-high-court

The Social Media Ban Is Finally in the High Court, Thanks to Reddit and Two Teens

A teenager’s hands holding a phone with a blank screen in front of a grand court building with columns

Macy Neyland. Fifteen when the case got filed. Same with Noah Jones. Both reckoned the under-16 social media ban shut them out.

Don’t like kids on social media? Stay off it yourself, Macy said last year. Just don’t make her.

Now it’s in the High Court. Hearings started Tuesday. They’re running over two days.

Who’s suing?

Two lots of challengers.

First, the Digital Freedom Project. It’s an advocacy group. John Ruddick runs it. He’s a Libertarian MP in the NSW upper house. Macy and Noah are part of that case.

Then Reddit. It filed days later.

Reddit wants the law struck out. It also wants the court to say it isn’t an “age-restricted social media platform” at all.

Its pitch, in an earlier filing? It’s a site for sharing knowledge between users. Not really about following people.

The court has joined the two challenges into one case. Back in December, Chief Justice Stephen Gageler said Reddit’s issues would be dealt with first.

Ruddick didn’t hold back when the case was filed. A “direct assault” on young people’s right to political communication, he called it.

What’s the argument?

It comes down to something called the implied freedom of political communication.

It’s not written in the Constitution. The High Court found it back in the 1990s. Why? Voters have to be able to talk politics. Otherwise how do they vote? It’s not absolute, though.

The ban cuts young people out of civic life, the challengers say.

Reddit’s lawyers went further. Kids can’t speak, organise or reach an audience quickly and cheaply anymore, they argued.

There’s a “fundamental disconnect” too, their written submissions said. Plenty of under-16s have dodged the age checks. And a lot of the harmful stuff is still there without an account.

Better options were available, they reckon.

What’s the government saying?

It’s about protecting kids from harm. That’s the Commonwealth’s line.

The problem is how platforms are built, its lawyers will argue. Ad money. Keep people scrolling. Keep them coming back.

Political freedom is about electors anyway, they say. People old enough to vote. So any burden on kids is “indirect, modest and justified”.

“We will stand firm to protect young Australians from experiencing harm on social media,” a government spokesperson said.

State attorneys-general have sided with the Commonwealth. WA, NSW and South Australia all put their hands up.

The government lost its top lawyer along the way. Solicitor-General Stephen Donaghue KC left last December. He took a spot on Victoria’s Court of Appeal.

Overseas groups have piled in on the other side. Britain’s Free Speech Union. NetChoice, a US tech industry group. The Electronic Frontier Foundation as well.

How’s the ban actually going?

It started on 10 December last year.

Ten platforms are covered. Facebook, Instagram, Threads, Snapchat, TikTok, X and YouTube. Reddit, Kick and Twitch too.

Platforms have to take “reasonable steps” to keep under-16s off. Miss that and fines can hit $49.5 million.

How do they check age? Government ID. Facial age estimation. Or age inference. They have to offer something other than ID.

Gaming, health and education platforms got broad exemptions.

Nearly 5 million accounts have been blocked so far.

The PM was pretty happy with it back in January. “We want our kids to have a childhood and parents to know we have their backs,” Anthony Albanese said.

Still, research from June suggested as many as 80 per cent of under-16s were still using social media. That’s from AAP.

Reddit’s still following the rules while the case runs. Adam Collins is its communications chief. They’ll keep complying while they fight it, he said.

Kids’ wellbeing keeps coming up this year, mind you. Even sport. There’s been warnings about kids playing one sport too young.

Could the government lose?

Luke Beck doesn’t think so. He’s a constitutional law professor at Monash Uni.

The government has a strong case, he reckons.

“It’s very clear that the Commonwealth can regulate social media and online spaces.”

Even if it does lose, it might just be a “technical breach”, he said. Fixable with a few tweaks.

Noam Peleg sees it differently. He’s a children’s rights expert.

“They are removed from public spaces. They are removed from their ability to exercise their own citizenship,” he told AAP.

Australia’s ranked 142nd out of 194 countries on the KidsRights Index, AAP noted.

Meanwhile? A digital duty of care bill. Labor’s pushing it. It would put the onus on platforms to make their systems safer.

There’s no date for a judgment yet.